
Jordan told me he waited his whole life for this moment. He was ready to propose to the love of his life, Kayla, and he knew it had to happen somewhere meaningful. Growing up in Fort Myers, it felt right to propose during their vacation back home to visit his parents. When we met on a Zoom call to talk through the details, Jordan made it clear just how important it was for him to have me there. His excitement made me feel incredibly valued and honored to be their proposal photographer.

For the location, we settled on the Sanibel Lighthouse, an iconic Southwest Florida landmark that would be the perfect backdrop for this Sanibel proposal. A few days before the proposal, I met Jordan’s parents at the lighthouse to walk the location and plan for positioning. We talked through where Jordan and Kayla would walk, where I could stay hidden, and how everything would unfold. Having that time to scout and prepare made the day itself feel seamless.






On the day of the proposal, I set myself up as a “casual tourist” and waited for them to walk onto the beach. From afar, I secretly captured their private, intimate moment as Jordan got down on one knee. Kayla was completely unaware of me until I walked up afterward to congratulate them. That’s when the next surprise came out. Butterflies are a significant symbol in their relationship, and Jordan’s parents joined us with a box of butterflies to release. They released them together under the shade of the trees.






As golden light filtered through the greenery and butterflies fluttered around us, we wrapped up their engagement photos. We laughed and moved quickly as the no-see-ums reminded us this was a very real Southwest Florida evening. The butterflies slowly scattered across the island, settling into their new home, marking the end of a beautiful Sanibel proposal.











If you’re also planning a Sanibel proposal or Southwest Florida engagement photos, I would love to help! You can contact me here.
Showit template designed by Little Hound Creative
customized by amanda feltz photography
@amandafeltzphotography
Amanda Feltz Photography is a lifestyle and storytelling photographer specializing in elopements, proposals, and family sessions. Based in Fort Myers and serving Southwest Florida, Chicago, and beyond.